Jesse Newhart Rotating Header Image

Why Is Facebook Trying To Be Twitter?

Facebook is driving me crazy.  Only a few days after I made a post talking about how Facebook differs from Twitter and why I was changing how I use the Facebook service that Facebook decides to make major changes and become more like Twitter.

The gist of my previous post was that Facebook was meant more for connecting with personal friends and family while services like Twitter and LinkedIn led themselves more to networking. That is why Facebook has the privacy controls and the limit as to the number of friends you can have.  

I also talked about how the seemingly proper way to network with the newly overhauled Facebook ‘pages’ where you can setup a Facebook presence for your business, project or personal brand and through participation in Facebook groups.

Not soon afterwords I noticed how Facebook changed their homepage to become more Twitter like.  Now today I see that Facebook is loosening privacy controls making it easier for a users personal data to be viewable to search engines and to other Facebook users.

This is starting to piss me off, especially after deleting over 200 Facebook contacts, which it really did pain me to do,  in order to align myself better with the spirit of their service.  I began reserving my Facebook personal profile for family and close personal friends only with a promise to set up a Facebook ‘page’ so that I could communicate with my FB social media contacts, colleagues and co-workers.

At this point I am sticking to that plan, but I really wish that Facebook would make up it’s fucking mind and stay true to the spirit of their service that made them one of the fastest growing websites on the planet.  Why change to emulate Twitter when supposedly Facebook grows a Twitter’s worth of new users every week?

Is it just me or is Facebook so scared of ‘the next big thing’ that they have forgotten that they are the big social network on campus, which they are….for now.

Please leave a comment telling me what you think.  I’d love to hear how you feel about Facebook’s recent changes.

  • Wow, I couldn't agree more! Facebook is where I connect with people I know. On Twitter, it's more networking between people all around the world (I only actually know 3 of the people I'm following). So far, barely any of my friends is using the live home page as intended (to compete with Twitter). The only ones that are, are using the Twitter app to automatically update their Facebook with their tweets. Which sort of annoys me because the @replys and hashtags really have no baring in Facebook.

    I'm fine with change, that's not my issue. My issue is how they are trying to adapt and change the purpose and functionality of Facebook to compete with what I feel is a different service.
  • I agree. Facebook has followed the social media trends smartly in the past to keep Facebook feeling modern. But now they are almost on the verge of imitating the hottest social media trend. I have to say I do like the new layout.. but I also like Twitter so that could be why!
  • JC
    Luckily, I have limited my facebook profile to real-life friends and family from the beginning. I am not a high-profile person and see no reason in adding folks at random and call them my "friends." On the contrary, I do understand why people elect to include random people as means of self-promotion. I can understand where you're coming from.

    I did not like Facebook from the beginning. I joined because my best friend sent me an invite. Ever since I joined Facebook got a lot of bad press, all the reason for me to dislike it even more. I held on because it was rather a unique social network. Obviously I can no longer say that, and I predict very soon Facebook will lose its luster just like Myspace.
  • I haven't really delved into Facebook's new look yet. I do agree that they need to recognize who and what they are and stay within that. There's a tendency to try to do too much, to be everything to everyone, that never works. I hope they don't fall into that trap.
  • djah
    Facebook is a social private network, and it never will be a twitter, i guess
  • The spirit of facebook was always best represented as a lifestream, and occasional update platform, and not an instant microblog - as is with twitter. The changes have downgraded facebook's importance to me for sure, as well as countless readers on my social media blog.

    The whole concept for facebook was to connect with people over the years, and have an inlet to their various changes and activities, as in "occasional" shout outs and "what's up's". I personally have friends on facebook that I've known since the 3rd grade, and while it is interesting to know when they win a golf game, have a great time in Bali, or remarry, I just don't want to know what kind of coffee they may be drinking - at this very second. And I really don't want to let most of these friends know what I'm doing right now either.

    In the first place I have twitter already for that purpose, which BTW pi$$es me off that facebook can just bite from another website unnecessarily. In the second place - moving from "occasional" bulletin board-like updates to instant conversational updates really ignores the core purpose of the facebook experience IMO. It was the worst update of any website I have seen in a while, and a very Microsoft-y thing to do.

    What ever happened to the business acumen "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" ? Facebook fails now. Period.
  • When I started freelance writing, I made my Facebook profile private because a couple of readers who didn't like what I had to say started looking up things about me online. They were harmless at the time, but I figured if I wanted to use Facebook to connect with close friends and family (which makes sense considering that we share a lot of our old photos there), I should just make it private. If they're going to loosen the privacy controls, I'm not sure how I'll modify my usage. I really don't want to quit using it completely, but I'm definitely getting tired of the constant changes. What ever happened to sticking with what works?
  • I'm also disappointed by Facebook's identity crisis. Like you, I prefer to use Facebook and Twitter to interact with different audiences and for different reasons. Sheesh!
  • After catching my breath, and ridding myself of the alarm that accompanies change - this has been my constant stance.

    "Okay, some of this FB stuff is just "different..." Whatever, but lack of Live Feed is still WRONG! I already have a Twitter account."

    Your take on LinkedIn with Twitter in comparison to FB merits some consideration.

    One wonders if the FB folks will figure it out.
  • ifan
    The new interface is very annoying, but I can tolerate it.

    However, I found their new default privacy setting does not respect our privacy at all, and this will push me leave facebook someday.
blog comments powered by Disqus